Fundraising: The Nonprofit vs. For-Profit Double Standard

Key Takeaways from Dan Pallotta’s TED Talk on Charity and Fundraising

There is no reason why a nonprofit should be making less money than for-profit companies…other than the stigma that holds it back from doing so. In order to increase your donations and mission success, you have to understand the reason for this roadblock and how a small mind shift can change everything.

In his TED Talk, “The way we think about charity is dead wrong,” Dan Pallotta explores the unfair disadvantage nonprofits have compared to the rest of the economic world. He states that we have a belief system that discriminates against and consistently keeps nonprofits small. Perhaps, if we can change this belief system, we can allow nonprofits to have a fighting chance in our economy.

Five Double Standards Hindering Nonprofits

1. Nonprofit Compensation

In contrast to for-profit companies, the more money you make as a nonprofit, the more negatively people react to it.

Pallota offers a very stark illustration:

“…You want to make 50 million dollars selling violent video games to kids, go for it. We’ll put you on the cover of Wired magazine. But you want to make half a million dollars trying to cure kids of malaria, and you’re considered a parasite yourself.”

2. Advertising and Marketing

People take issue with donating money that does not go directly to the needy. Consumer brands are allowed—and encouraged—to spend money on advertising and marketing. Nonprofits, however, are told to keep it to a minimum.

Since the 1970s, nonprofits have remained stuck at 2% of GDP. If we allow consumer brands to market, but not nonprofits, they will never be able to take market share away from other sectors.

How many companies crossed the $50 million annual revenue barrier between 1970-2009?
144

Nonprofits crossed the $50M annual revenue threshold

46,136

For-Profits crossed the $50M annual revenue threshold

3. Nonprofit Innovation

Nonprofits are reluctant to attempt any new and daring ideas for fear of ruining their reputations by not providing return on investment to their beneficiaries.

“…when you prohibit failure, you kill innovation. If you kill innovation in fundraising, you can’t raise more revenue; if you can’t raise more revenue, you can’t grow; and if you can’t grow, you can’t possibly solve large social problems.”

4. Time

People allot more patience to for-profit companies to take the years they need to build market dominance before any money goes back to the investors. A nonprofit can never take the same amount of time before any money goes to the needy or risk its end.

5. Profits and Overhead

Donors perceive overhead costs as a negative, even though they are imperative to the nonprofit’s growth.

“…we have it precisely backwards, and we should be investing more money, not less, in fundraising, because fundraising is the one thing that has the potential to multiply the amount of money available for the cause that we care about so deeply.”

Confusing Nonprofit Morality with Frugality

Our society’s views on what is “morally superior” holds nonprofits back from netting a much greater sum for their causes. A bake sale with 5% overhead seems to provide a better return than (and is therefore morally superior to) a professional fundraising enterprise with 40% overhead, because of the slice of the pie consumed by the costs. But when we compare the two, we are missing the most significant information: the size of the pies generated.

Which does more for a cause after expenses:
95% of $71 “pie” or 60% of $71M “pie”?
Nonprofit fundraiser - bake sale
$71

Total generated by a bakesale with 5% ($3.55) overhead

Nonprofit fundraiser - marathon
$71,000,000

Total generated by an enterprise effort with 40% ($28.4M) overhead

Pallotta believes in the importance of investing in your nonprofit’s scale. He had a very successful fundraising organization which suddenly and traumatically had to let go of all 350 of their employees. Their sponsors had pulled out when the media negatively covered their decisions to invest in recruitment, customer service, and advertising. Overhead had been demonized despite its necessity and the incredible success it produced ($194 million dollars for breast cancer research). As a result, the following year’s breast cancer research funding went down by $60 million dollars.

Action Steps: Changing the Double Standard

  • Focus on the Right Metrics: The Impact You Make

    Shift the mindset in your own organization, and then in the rest of the world. The only metric that should truly matter is the difference you make. If your “overhead” is what allows you to grow, to reach more people and to compete with for-profit companies so that you can do more good, then don’t apologize for it.

  • Take More Risks

    Take more “risks” and encourage fellow nonprofits to do the same. Try new programs and new approaches to marketing what you do. Not all campaigns and programs will succeed, but if nonprofits are to ever collect more than the current 2% of GDP, nonprofits have to experiment and innovate.

  • Compete with For-Profits!

    There is no reason why nonprofits can’t (or at least shouldn’t) compete with for-profits for people’s attention and discretionary funds. Many of the tools that for-profits use can be just as effective for organizations focused on impact—especially when it comes to online tools, which are often inexpensive or even free for nonprofits. We’re constantly adding to our curated list of tech your dotOrg can use, in our nonprofit tools section.

  • Watch the full TED Talk

    There’s a reason why this talk has been watched over 4,000,000 times. Even if you watched it before, it’s worth worth 18 minutes to remind you about how we should be thinking about charity.

Get the latest articles and nonprofit online news that can boost your mission, right in your inbox:

[wp_colorbox_media url="#mcsignup" type="inline" hyperlink="Get our Newsletter" class="avia-button avia-button-fullwidth avia-icon_select-no avia-color-grey hover_blue"]

Want help with these strategies or other ways of increasing your impact? We’re happy to help.

Our course offers a great way to think about (and execute on) your online goals.